An effective payroll system does more than distribute paychecks; it supports compliance, strengthens employee engagement, and optimizes business operations. However, success lies in the details — precise calculations, compliance checks, and streamlined processes ensure everything runs seamlessly.

When every element is carefully managed, the result is a reliable, accurate payroll process that ensures employees are paid on time, every time.

But with evolving regulations and the increasing need for automation, how can businesses refine their payroll processes in 2025? In this article, we’ll explore 10 essential payroll best practices every employer should follow to build a smoother, more efficient payroll system.

Let’s dive in!

Establish Structured Payroll Guidelines

A well-defined payroll policy is the backbone of an efficient, error-free payroll system. Without clear guidelines, payroll processing can become inconsistent, leading to confusion, compliance risks, and potential disputes. Setting up detailed payroll procedures ensures accuracy, transparency, and smooth operations.

To create an effective payroll policy, employers should:

✔ Define pay periods and methods – Establish whether employees are paid weekly, biweekly, or monthly and clarify if payments will be made via direct deposit or check.

✔ Outline timekeeping procedures – Specify how employees should record their hours and how time sheets are reviewed.

✔ Detail tax withholdings and deductions – Document federal, state, and local tax requirements along with any voluntary deductions (e.g., benefits or retirement contributions).

✔ Establish overtime and bonus calculations – Ensure compliance with labor laws regarding overtime pay, shift differentials, and bonuses.

✔ Maintain a payroll calendar – Provide employees and payroll staff with a clear schedule of payroll deadlines, paydays, and tax filing dates.

✔ Regularly review for compliance – Labor laws change, and payroll policies should be updated accordingly to avoid costly penalties.

Investing in the right payroll software may help streamline these procedures, ensuring accuracy and reducing administrative burden. By setting clear payroll policies and communicating them effectively, businesses can prevent payroll errors, enhance employee trust, and maintain compliance with ease.

Don’t let taxes get you down. Make payroll easy with OnTheClock!

Your stress-free solution for payroll.

Schedule a Demo

Upgrade Your Payroll Software for Better Accuracy, Efficiency

Payroll management is complex, but the right software can simplify the process, reduce errors, and improve compliance. Investing in a modern payroll system allows companies to automate their time data, scheduling, and payroll services in one platform, not only saving time but also enhancing accuracy and ensuring employees are paid correctly and on time.

Modern payroll software, such as OnTheClock, automates essential tasks, such as:

✔ Time Tracking and Overtime Calculations – Eliminates manual errors and ensures fair compensation.

✔ Tax Calculations and Withholdings – Keeps up with changing tax laws to prevent compliance issues.

✔ Payroll Reporting and Cost Analysis – Provides real-time insights into labor costs and payroll trends.

✔ Automated Payments – Ensures timely direct deposits or check processing, reducing administrative burden.

✔ Integrated Benefits and Deductions Management – Simplifies benefits administration and wage garnishments.

By digitizing payroll, businesses can minimize human error, streamline operations, and free up time to focus on growth. Whether you’re a small business or a growing enterprise, adopting payroll automation is a strategic move that pays off in efficiency and compliance.

Prioritize Payroll Privacy & Secure Record Retention

Protecting sensitive payroll data and maintaining accurate records isn’t just good practice — it’s a legal necessity. Employers must safeguard employee information while ensuring payroll records are retained for the appropriate duration to meet compliance requirements.

Maintain Confidentiality & Secure Access

Payroll data includes sensitive details, such as Social Security numbers, bank account information, tax withholdings, and salary details. To protect this information:

✔ Limit access to authorized personnel only.

✔ Use encryption and secure storage for digital records.

✔ Implement strong password policies and multifactor authentication.

✔ Regularly audit payroll data to detect and address discrepancies.

Follow Legal Record Retention Guidelines

Federal laws, including the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), require businesses to retain payroll records for at least three years. However, additional state-specific laws may extend these retention periods. Key payroll documents to keep include:

✔ Employees' personal and employment records.

✔ Time sheets, pay stubs, and direct deposit details.

✔ Tax forms (W-4, W-2, and relevant state tax documents).

✔ Benefits and deduction records.

Digital vs. Physical Payroll Recordkeeping

Small businesses may opt for physical payroll records, but this can quickly become cumbersome. Fireproof lockboxes or secure filing systems are essential for protecting paper records. Midsized and large businesses will most certainly benefit from payroll software, which automates recordkeeping, ensures compliance, and provides easy access to reports.

No matter the method, ensure records are securely stored and properly disposed of when the retention period ends. By prioritizing payroll privacy and structured record retention, businesses can prevent data breaches, maintain compliance, and build employee trust.

Streamline Payroll Approvals for Accuracy & Efficiency

A structured payroll approval process is essential for ensuring accuracy, compliance, and timely payments. By clearly defining roles, setting approval checkpoints, and leveraging automation, businesses can eliminate bottlenecks and reduce errors in payroll processing.

Define Roles & Responsibilities

A seamless approval process starts with assigning the right people to review payroll data. Typically, HR, finance, and department managers should collaborate to verify:

✔ Employee time entries and overtime calculations.

✔ Tax withholdings and deductions.

✔ Payroll adjustments, bonuses, and reimbursements.

Set Approval Checkpoints & Deadlines

To keep payroll on schedule, establish:

✔ Cut-off dates for time sheet submissions and corrections.

✔ Deadlines for department heads to approve payroll changes.

✔ Final review checkpoints before processing payroll.

Automate for Speed & Accuracy

Manual approvals can slow payroll down. Payroll automation streamlines the process by:

✔ Eliminating redundant manual checks.

✔ Sending automatic reminders for pending approvals.

✔ Providing a transparent audit trail of approvals and edits.

By streamlining payroll approvals, businesses can reduce processing time, improve accuracy, and ensure every paycheck is right the first time, every time.

Classify Your Employees Accurately and Appropriately

Accurately classifying employees is critical for payroll compliance, ensuring proper tax withholding, benefits eligibility, and wage calculations. Misclassification can lead to hefty fines, IRS audits, and employee disputes — making it essential to get it right from the start.

Key Employee Classifications

Employees generally fall into these categories:

✔ Full-Time Employees – Typically work 40 hours per week, qualify for benefits, and receive a salary or hourly wage.

✔ Part-Time Employees – Work fewer hours than full-time employees and may have limited benefits.

✔ Temporary/Seasonal Employees – Hired for a set period or specific project; often ineligible for long-term benefits.

✔ Independent Contractors (1099 Workers) – Self-employed individuals responsible for their own taxes; employers do not withhold payroll taxes or provide benefits.

Additionally, employees must be classified as exempt or nonexempt under the FLSA. Nonexempt employees qualify for overtime pay, while exempt employees do not. Misclassifying a nonexempt employee as exempt can result in FLSA violations, back wages, and penalties.

The Risks of Misclassification

Incorrectly labeling employees, whether mistakenly or intentionally, can trigger:

🚨 IRS and Department of Labor (DOL) audits.

🚨 Fines and back payments for unpaid wages and benefits.

🚨 Class-action lawsuits from misclassified employees.

One example of a misclassification is Nike’s high-profile payroll mistake, which resulted in potential tax penalties exceeding $530 million, proving that even major corporations can face severe consequences.

How to Stay Compliant

✔ Review Job Roles – Use federal and state classification guidelines to determine whether a worker is an employee or contractor.

✔ Use the Right Tests – The IRS, DOL, and state agencies apply different criteria to distinguish between employees and contractors.

✔ Audit Regularly – Periodically reassess classifications to ensure compliance with changing labor laws.

Getting employee classification right from the start helps businesses avoid legal trouble, ensures fair wages, and keeps payroll running smoothly.

Stay Up to Date on All Tax Laws and Regulations

Payroll tax laws are constantly changing, and staying compliant isn’t just about meeting deadlines — it’s about protecting your business from costly penalties. Federal, state, and even local tax regulations can shift due to new legislation, economic factors, or policy updates. Keeping up with these changes ensures accurate payroll processing and helps you avoid IRS audits or fines.

Key Payroll Tax Considerations

✔ Federal, State, and Local Payroll Taxes – Your payroll must account for federal income tax, Social Security, Medicare, and state-specific requirements, like unemployment insurance or disability contributions. Some states also have unique paid family leave programs.

✔ Employee Classification – Misclassifying employees as independent contractors can result in unpaid payroll taxes and hefty fines. Regularly review classification rules under the FLSA.

✔ Minimum Wage Adjustments – Many states update their minimum wage annually, so it’s essential to track federal, state, and local rates to ensure compliance.

✔ Cross-Border and Remote Workforce Considerations – If you have employees in different states or countries, you must comply with multi-jurisdictional payroll tax laws. International hires may require additional reporting to avoid double taxation.

✔ Retroactive Tax Law Changes – Sometimes, tax laws change mid-year or even retroactively. If this happens, you may need to adjust payroll records and ensure back payments or credits are properly accounted for.

How to Stay Ahead of Payroll Tax Changes

✔ Monitor Tax Law Updates – Regularly check IRS announcements, state tax agency websites, and trusted payroll resources to stay informed.

✔ Use Payroll Software – Automated payroll solutions help track tax rates, update compliance requirements, and generate reports for accurate filing.

✔ Set Tax Filing Reminders – Payroll taxes are due on a strict schedule — usually quarterly. Mark your calendar to ensure timely submissions.

✔ Consult Payroll Professionals – If your business is growing or hiring across multiple locations, a tax professional or payroll provider can help navigate complex compliance requirements.

Conduct Regular Payroll Audits

Payroll mistakes can be costly for both your business and its employees. Conducting regular payroll audits helps catch discrepancies before they turn into compliance issues, ensuring employees are paid correctly and taxes are filed accurately. Whether you manage payroll in-house or use a payroll provider, routine audits help keep your payroll system running smoothly.

Types of Payroll Audits

✔ Internal Payroll Audit – This is a self-conducted audit that reviews payroll records, tax filings, and employee classifications. It’s a proactive way to identify and correct errors.

✔ External Payroll Audit – Conducted by a third-party professional, an external audit provides an unbiased review of payroll processes to ensure compliance and efficiency.

What to Review in a Payroll Audit

✔ Employee Pay Rates – Verify salaries, hourly wages, and overtime pay align with contracts and legal requirements.

✔ Time and Attendance Records – Cross-check timecards with payroll data to ensure accurate compensation.

✔ Tax Withholdings – Confirm federal, state, and local tax deductions are applied correctly based on employee W-4 forms.

✔ Benefit Contributions – Ensure deductions for health insurance, retirement plans, and other benefits are accurate and properly allocated.

✔ Garnishments and Deductions – Review court-ordered deductions, like child support or wage garnishments, to ensure compliance with legal requirements.

✔ Payroll Reports and Bank Reconciliations – Compare payroll records with bank statements to identify discrepancies in payments.

Why Payroll Audits Matter

✔ Ensure Accurate Payments – Employees expect their paychecks to be correct every time. An audit helps verify that wages, overtime, bonuses, and deductions are calculated properly.

✔ Maintain Tax Compliance – Payroll audits help confirm that tax withholdings, deposits, and filings align with federal, state, and local regulations.

✔ Verify Employee Information – Audits help catch misclassified employees, incorrect benefits deductions, and outdated tax forms that could affect payroll accuracy.

✔ Prevent Fraud and Errors – Regular reviews help detect unauthorized changes, duplicate payments, and potential fraud before they become major issues.

Best Practices for Payroll Audits

✔ Schedule Audits Regularly – Conduct audits quarterly or biannually to catch errors before they become major problems.

✔ Use Payroll Automation – Payroll software can flag inconsistencies and provide audit trails, making reviews more efficient.

✔ Involve HR and Finance Teams – Collaboration ensures accurate recordkeeping and alignment between payroll, employee records, and tax filings.

Incorporate Employee Feedback

Payroll isn’t just a back-office function — it directly impacts employees' financial well-being and job satisfaction. Ensuring a smooth and transparent payroll experience starts with listening to the people it affects most. By actively seeking employee feedback, businesses can identify pain points, enhance payroll efficiency, and improve overall satisfaction.

Why Employee Feedback Matters

✔ Enhances Accuracy & Efficiency – Employees can spot payroll discrepancies that may go unnoticed in routine processing.

✔ Builds Trust & Transparency – A company that listens to employee concerns fosters a more engaged and loyal workforce.

✔ Improves Payroll Processes – Feedback helps uncover issues like delays in direct deposits, confusing tax deductions, or missing overtime pay.

Best Practices for Gathering Payroll Feedback

✔ Use Employee Surveys – Conduct regular pulse surveys to assess how employees feel about the payroll process. Ask questions about paycheck accuracy, ease of accessing pay stubs, and the clarity of tax deductions.

✔ Encourage Open Communication – Create an environment where employees feel comfortable discussing payroll concerns. Offer multiple feedback channels, such as anonymous forms, HR meetings, or digital suggestion boxes.

✔ Monitor System Performance – If you use payroll software, track issues reported by employees and work with your provider to make necessary adjustments.

✔ Act on Feedback Quickly – Employees need to see that their input leads to real improvements. Address common concerns, update policies as needed, and communicate changes effectively.

By incorporating employee feedback, businesses can fine-tune their payroll processes, ensuring employees receive accurate, timely, and stress-free pay. A payroll system that listens and adapts isn’t just a business necessity — it’s a competitive advantage.

Scalability and Future-Proofing

Your payroll system needs to do more than meet today’s demands — it must be prepared for tomorrow’s growth. Whether you're adding employees, expanding into new locations, or navigating evolving labor laws, a scalable payroll system ensures that growth doesn’t come at the cost of efficiency.

If your payroll system isn’t built for growth, you may face inefficiencies, compliance risks, and unnecessary administrative burdens. Future-proofing your payroll means adopting solutions that can adapt and scale alongside your business.

Best Practices for Scalable Payroll

✔ Choose a Flexible Payroll Solution – Select software that can accommodate an increasing number of employees, multiple pay structures, and compliance with different tax jurisdictions. Look for cloud-based platforms that offer automation, integration, and multi-location support.

✔ Ensure Seamless System Integrations – Your payroll should connect effortlessly with HR, accounting, and benefits systems to reduce redundancies and streamline financial management. Integration ensures smooth workflows as your business scales.

✔ Automate Everything – Automation eliminates manual errors, reduces processing time, and allows your payroll team to focus on strategic growth initiatives. Features like direct deposit, tax filings, and employee self-service portals can make payroll more efficient as your team expands.

✔ Document Payroll Processes – Establish clear, detailed payroll procedures to simplify onboarding new payroll staff and ensure consistency. A well-documented system prevents disruptions as your business grows.

✔ Build Redundancy & Cross-Training – Avoid single points of failure by cross-training employees on payroll tasks. This ensures payroll runs smoothly even if a key team member is unavailable.

✔ Regularly Review and Adapt – Periodically assess your payroll system to identify potential bottlenecks. Ask yourself: If our workforce doubled overnight, could our payroll system handle it? If the answer is no, it’s time to refine your strategy.

✔ Growth Without Payroll Bottlenecks – By prioritizing scalability and future-proofing your payroll processes, you ensure growth doesn’t lead to inefficiencies or compliance risks. A payroll system built for expansion gives you the freedom to focus on growing your business — not fixing payroll issues.

Simplify Payroll with a Comprehensive Solution

Managing payroll doesn’t have to be complicated. The more systems you juggle — time tracking, tax calculations, scheduling, direct deposits, etc. — the more room there is for errors, inefficiencies, and compliance risks. That’s why an all-in-one payroll solution is a game-changer.

The Benefits of an Integrated Payroll System

✅ Fewer Errors, Less Hassle – When payroll and time tracking work together seamlessly, there’s no need for manual data entry or cross-checking hours. Everything is accurate, automated, and easy to manage.

✅ Time Saved, Money Saved – Processing payroll shouldn’t take hours of your day. An integrated system streamlines the entire process, so you can focus on running your business, not crunching numbers.

✅ Stress-Free Compliance – Staying compliant with tax regulations and labor laws is easier when your payroll system automatically calculates withholdings, overtime, and tax filings.

✅ Happier Employees – Timely, error-free paychecks build trust and keep your team happy. Employee self-service options allow workers to access pay stubs, update information, and manage direct deposits without extra admin work.

OnTheClock Payroll: Time Tracking + Scheduling + Payroll in One Simple Platform

OnTheClock has been helping businesses track employee hours for 20-plus years, and now, with built-in payroll, you can manage everything in one place. No spreadsheets, no exporting data — just an effortless payroll process from start to finish.

If you’re looking for a simple, reliable payroll solution that works seamlessly with time tracking, OnTheClock Payroll is designed for you. Learn more about how OnTheClock Payroll can simplify your payroll process today at www.ontheclock.com/payroll.aspx!