Why Evening Shifts Matter: Exploring the Impact and Benefits

Why Evening Shifts Matter: Exploring the Impact and Benefits

How evening shifts fuel productivity and workforce flexibility
Evening Shifts

During the late 18th and early 19th centuries, as factories and other industries started to operate around the clock to increase productivity, the need for greater output led to the establishment of shifts – specific timeframes that allowed employees to work at different times throughout the day. 

Initially, employees were expected to work 12-hour shifts (or longer), but as labor laws evolved and workers’ rights movements gained momentum, working hours were gradually reduced to eight hours, which became a federal standard in many industries. And, when split into three eight-hour shifts, employers had a convenient way to cover all 24 hours in a day. 

This article will specifically examine the evening (or late) shift, define its parameters, explore its importance, and more. 

Defining the Evening Shift

Evening shifts refer to work hours that extend beyond regular daytime operations, typically starting in the late afternoon and ending late at night. Unlike morning shifts that begin at the start of the day, evening shifts usually start around 3-4 p.m. and conclude between 11 p.m. and midnight. This arrangement bridges the gap between daytime and nighttime activities, ensuring continuous service that meets the needs of both businesses and consumers.

According to OSHA, almost 15 million employees work full time on evening, night, rotating, or other irregular shifts. In 2017-2018, Redline reported that 84% of wage and salary workers had a regular daytime schedule. The other 16% worked non-day hours, including 6% in the evenings and 4% at night. The rest had rotating, split, irregular, or other schedules.

Different Types of Evening Shifts

Evening shift hours offer a range of scheduling options to meet various organizational needs and employee preferences, each providing unique benefits and flexibility for both employers and employees. Different types of evening shifts, often tailored to the specific needs of industries and organizations, include part- and full-time work. Here are a few common variations that answer the question: How long is an evening shift?

Swing Shift: Swing shifts typically start in the early afternoon and overlap with both the day and night shifts. They may run from around 2-10 p.m. or 3-11 p.m., providing coverage during peak activity hours and ensuring a smooth transition between daytime and nighttime operations.

Second Shift: Often referred to simply as the "evening shift," the second shift generally starts mid-afternoon and ends late at night. Common hours might be from 4 p.m. to midnight. This shift is standard in industries that operate around the clock, such as health care, manufacturing, and customer service.

Mid Shift: Mid shift falls between the day and night shifts but generally starts later than the traditional swing shift. Hours might range from 5 p.m. to 1 a.m. This shift can help bridge staffing needs during late business hours and early nighttime activities.

Afternoon Shift: A variant of the evening shift that begins earlier, around noon to 2 p.m., and ends in the evening, typically by 8 p.m. or 10 p.m., is often used in retail, hospitality, and service industries to cover busy late afternoon and early evening periods.

Split Shift: This shift involves working two separate shifts in one day with a significant break in between. An employee might work from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m., take a break, and then return for an evening shift from 5-9 p.m. This setup is common in industries like transportation and hospitality.

Common Jobs and Industries that Utilize Evening Shifts

According to Redline, 3.6% of all workers worked night shifts, with the highest rates among transportation/material-moving workers (5.3%) and production workers (9.1%). The industries with the highest rates of night shift work were manufacturing (5.7%), transportation/utilities (6.3%), and leisure/hospitality (2.6%). Here is a further breakdown of a few industries that commonly staff employees in the evening. 

Entertainment, Sports, and Media: Musicians, directors, and broadcast technicians are among the workers who help to entertain or inform audiences into the evening. Hotels, movie theaters, casinos, and other entertainment venues regularly hire people to work between 6-10 p.m. Evening work also may be common at places such as nail salons and retail establishments. 

Food Service: Waiters and waitresses, bartenders, and fast-food workers often work during evening hours. This occupation group had high percentages of workers who, for example, covered the dinner shift at restaurants and other eating places. 

Personal Care and Services: After work, many people try to find time for leisure or personal care activities. As a result, workers, such as hairdressers, fitness trainers, and skincare specialists, frequently are on the job at 6 p.m. or later.

Sales: This group had a relatively high percentage of people working earlier in the evening. But because many stores close by 10 p.m., the percentage was lower than average at that time. Examples of occupations in the group are retail sales workers, real estate sales agents, and cashiers.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Evening Shifts

Evening work hours present both advantages and challenges for employers and employees. Understanding these dynamics is essential for effective workforce management and creating a supportive work environment. This section examines the benefits for employers and the challenges employees face with evening shift schedules.

Benefits for Employers

Access to a Wider Talent Pool: Evening shifts attract a diverse range of individuals, including those with nontraditional schedules, caregiving responsibilities, or educational commitments. By accommodating employees who prefer nonstandard hours, employers can access untapped talent, enriching their workforce with varied perspectives and skills.

Improved Flexibility and Operations: Incorporating evening shifts increases organizational flexibility, allowing businesses to respond quickly to changing market demands, seasonal fluctuations, or unforeseen events. Extended hours enable companies to reach a larger customer base, optimize resource use, and generate revenue beyond typical business hours.

Enhanced Customer Service: Evening shifts improve customer service by offering around-the-clock support and accessibility. Extended service hours help meet the needs of customers outside of regular business hours, handle urgent inquiries, and build stronger customer relationships based on reliability and trust.

Challenges for Employers

Staffing and Retention: Recruiting and retaining employees for evening shifts can be difficult, as this timeframe does not appeal to all. This discontent may lead to a high turnover rate, leading to increased training and recruiting costs. 

Safety Concerns: Working into the night may raise security concerns for workers, especially those who commute. This may result in an investment in security equipment to ensure workers remain safe. 

Increased Wages: Oftentimes, because evening shifts are often less desirable than day shifts, compensation may be higher. These expenditures can increase the overall budget and impact profitability. 

Benefits for Employees

Flexible Scheduling: If employees have commitments during the day, a flexible evening work schedule may be more compatible with their schedules. 

Higher Pay: Many companies offer higher pay for employees who take less considerable shifts, such as evening hours. While higher pay may be considered a negative for employers, it’s often a positive for employees.  

Experience and Advancement: Employees working evening shifts may gain unique opportunities for advancement, especially in industries where continuous operation is crucial. Working such hours also shows a strong commitment to the organization. 

Challenges for Employees

Work-Life Balance Issues: Evening shifts can disrupt traditional work-life balance, making it challenging for employees to juggle professional responsibilities with personal commitments. The strain of managing work alongside family duties, social activities, and personal interests can lead to stress, fatigue, and burnout.

Impact on Personal Commitments: Evening shifts may limit employees' abilities to participate in family activities, social events, or other personal obligations. The mismatch between evening work hours and societal norms can make it difficult to maintain meaningful relationships, potentially leading to feelings of isolation or disconnection.

Stress and Fatigue: Evening shifts can be mentally and physically taxing. This can be further exacerbated when workers struggle to balance other responsibilities, including rest. 

Health and Lifestyle Adjustments for Evening Shifts

Now that we’ve looked at the pros and cons associated with working evening hours, let’s take a deeper dive into the physical and mental toll these shifts can wage. 

Generally speaking, evening shifts are more taxing than day shifts. A National Library of Medicine study suggests that working evening shifts has a negative effect on employees’ mental health. Common issues include lack of sleep, which may lead to cardiovascular issues, psychological problems, oncological concerns, and even reproductive issues. For example, in the meta-analysis, a positive relationship was found between long-term night work and the risk of breast, digestive, and skin cancer, i.e., the risk of breast cancer increased by 3.3% for every five years of night work. 

To overcome the unique challenges evening shifts present, consider making a few practical adjustments, including improving your sleep hygiene (falling asleep and waking up at the same times), nutrition (balanced meals, limited snacking, hydration, etc.), exercise, and more. 

Technology and Tools for Evening Shift Management

Employees working evening hours often juggle other commitments, making it essential to have a system that can accommodate flexibility without compromising coverage. Time tracking is a great way for employees and employers to manage these complexities seamlessly.

With time tracking, such as OnTheClock, one can easily manage and assign evening shifts using intuitive tools, such as scheduling features. If a last-minute change needs to be made to the evening schedule due to an unexpected absence, it can be done quickly and efficiently. Instead of frantically calling around or manually adjusting a spreadsheet, you simply log into the software and, with just a few clicks, reassign the shift to another qualified employee, ensuring that every role is covered.

Managing evening shifts can be challenging, but it also presents a unique opportunity to optimize workforce productivity and accommodate a diverse range of employee needs. By understanding the various types of evening shifts and their impact on both employers and employees, businesses can create a more inclusive and flexible work environment that attracts top talent and meets the demands of today’s 24/7 economy.

Imagine a restaurant bustling with diners during the late hours, a health care facility providing critical care around the clock, or a tech support team assisting customers in different time zones. In each of these scenarios, effective evening shift management is crucial to maintaining smooth operations and ensuring customer satisfaction. This is where tools like time tracking come into play, offering the flexibility and efficiency needed to manage schedules seamlessly. With features that allow for quick shift changes, accurate time tracking, and comprehensive reporting, new technologies and approaches help organizations navigate the complexities of evening shifts with ease.

As businesses continue to evolve and adapt to the changing landscape of work, leveraging technology to streamline operations is more important than ever. By embracing tools that simplify shift management, companies can not only improve their bottom lines but also create a supportive environment where employees can thrive, regardless of the time of day. After all, a well-managed evening shift is not just about covering hours — it's about building a workplace that works for everyone.

OnTheClock Employee Time Tracking

Written by

Herb Woerpel

Herb Woerpel is a copywriter with OnTheClock. He has 17-plus years of professional journalism experience working for community and national media outlets.

Do you want to know more about how OnTheClock works?

Leave Your Thoughts...

(required, will be shown)
(required, will not be shown)